Narnia and Polly and Glen Waddell
I just read Polly Toynbee’s review of the new Narnia movie. It was somewhat similar to other reviews I’ve recently read.
Apparently, reviewers who are not familiar with the books are being taken by surprise. Shouldn’t there be some kind of IQ requirement? Shouldn’t there be some kind of rule that before a critic is allowed to review a movie based on a book, that critic must first read the book?
On second thought, why should that be a rule? Isn’t it just common sense? Wouldn’t it be a sign of, oh, say, asininity, to set oneself up as some kind of expert about a movie based on a book, if one has not yet read the book?
This woman states that the movie is very faithful to the book, even though she never mentions that she has read it, and then proceeds to tear it to pieces because of her fear that it might give children cause to think about and recognize Christianity later in their lives. She advises non-believers to take a sickbag to the theater.
Oh Polly, Polly, Polly. . . . regardless of what you think, or what anyone thinks, your review falls into the same category as any other review: opinion.
In other words, your review, like any review, contains very little fact; it contains only your slant on your personal interpretation of a studio’s slant on their personal interpretation of a very good book. (MY slant and personal interpretation.)
Is mine any better than yours? No. I know many people who found fault with the film. But I run with a crowd that loves finding fault with book-based movies, because we are first and foremost book lovers, and we hate it when a movie leaves things out.
I’m not complaining about you having an opinion that’s different than mine. Heck, that’s what this country is all about! It would be pretty boring if we all thought alike.
Perhaps, however, if we all stopped putting each other and things down because of those differences, we might all get along somewhat better than we do now. I need to take this advice as much as you do.
Why can’t a reviewer acknowledge the Biblical allegory, accept it without whining, praise the wit and cleverness and subtlety or non-subtlety of it, and move on? Why is it that anything ‘religious’ is an open invitation to harsher criticism than, say, something “trashy” or “immoral” or “violent?” Why is a movie about child molesters ‘artistic’ and ‘touching,’ while a movie with religious implications is ‘propaganda?’ Why do we refer to an abuser as ‘handsome yet monstrous’ and say things like ‘I couldn’t help liking him a lot anyway,’ but to mention anything religious as being ‘good for us’ is out of line? Why would a movie like this be called “a fine piece of filmmaking, and something any true film lover should see,” while a movie like Narnia is “. . .heavily laden with guilt, blame, sacrifice and a suffering that is dark with emotional sadism”?
Whether you like it or not, this country uses a lot of Biblical references and allegories in everyday life. You’ve acknowledged that in your article. This country also uses a lot of mythological references and allegories in everyday life. You don’t seem to mind that. This country uses all KINDS of references and allegories, in every possible category and genre, in everyday life. People who understand them are considered educated and probably more intelligent than people who don’t understand them. What’s up with that little difference in your personal slant?
What, you didn’t understand all the allegories? I rest my case.
I'm starting to shop today. Right after this rant.
Okay, so, today’s what, the 15th?
I am a Christmas fanatic. I live for this season. I LOVE this time of year, the anticipatory days, the buildup, the whole atmosphere of the world. Well, of the fun world, anyway; the grinches and grumps of the world don’t count. I believe in the TRUE meaning of Christmas, but if you don’t, that’s your business. I do think even non-believers could get into the SEASON, if not the REASON, and have a lot of fun with it, and most of them do and are glad of it. But every party needs a pooper, that’s why we invited you. . . . . so sit in the corner and complain and try to ruin it for the majority of the nation, go ahead, whine away, oh boo hoo your rights are being trampled because other people (who constitute a majority, by the way) are all happy and singing. . . oh, grow up and look around, you loser!!! Most of us are happier than usual, and thinking of others and trying to make our personal spaces a little prettier, and thinking generous thoughts for a change, and trying to help others in the coldest time of the year, and you’re picketing stores and writing editorials demanding your scroogeish rights and doing your best to put a damper on it all.
Shame on you.
And, shame again. Lighten up. Embrace the emotional impact, if you don’t have it in you to embrace any other aspect of it. It’s a religious thing, yes. But it’s also a cultural thing, and a seasonal thing, and an emotional thing, and a love thing, and a caring thing, and a sharing thing, and it makes people happy when they participate, and if you choose not to participate in any part of it, at least shut up about it so you don’t drag others down with you. You have your rights? Yes, you do. And so do the rest of us, and that’s something you don’t seem to wish to acknowledge in any way because you’re too busy trying to get an entire culture to shut down and do things your way. It’s not going to happen, Scrooge. If you don’t like it, move away.
Yes. Move away. You know, to some OTHER country where you’re allowed to worship, behave, believe, eat, drink, etc, exactly as you please. . . . . oops. Um, wait a second. IS there another country where you’re allowed to do those things? Besides this one that you spend all your time putting down?
I don’t THINK so.
Therefore, if you intend to stay here, please understand something: you have your rights, and so does everyone else. You choose to be joyless at this time of year, others choose to be joyful. Neither of us is going to change. There are more of us than of you. Stay in your dark cheerless house if you don’t want to see happy sharing singing people.
Sit there in your dark hole and practice saying things like “Bah, humbug,” and “My RIGHTS are being obstructed!!!! Oh WAHHHHH” Stuff like that. Be sure your windows are open so the neighbors can hear you. Put a sign on your door, too, to warn people away lest a neighbor bring you a cake or a box of cookies – more signs that your rights are being disrespected.
What’s the matter, you can’t enjoy someone else’s holiday? Okay, then you should be the one who volunteers to work the Christmas shifts for people. It doesn’t mean anything to you, right? You’ll get more money, and that’s important to you, right? Then why aren’t you first in line for that? It would be a wonderful gift for a father or mother who would love to be home with their kids for Christmas. . . .but then, you don’t give gifts, do you, so that’s out. And asking you to work when others don’t would be yet another manisfestation of your rights being trampled.
Honestly. I hope you are in therapy.
But I digress. It’s the 15th of December, and I haven’t done any shopping yet. So I’m leaving for school early, and stopping by a few stores. My kids are going to have some kind of Christmas this year, and I don’t care if Hub and I don’t eat for a month afterwards. We don’t need to be eating, anyway, gad.
So, to the majority of the world, a very Merry Christmas. To the rest of you, carry on, and be careful lest you accidently eat a cookie or hear a song or see some twinkling lights; it might scar you for life.
You know, I really believe that a person who chooses to live in a certain place, should bend over backwards to learn the language, the customs, and adapt to the culture. Otherwise, go back. Plus, it is not the responsibility, nor should it be, of the nation to accommodate the language, customs, and culture from whence you came. If you wanted to keep that wholly unto itself, why did you come to another place and expect to be catered to? If I moved to another country, I would certainly not expect, let alone demand or require, anyone or anything to cater to me; it would be my responsibility to adapt myself. I would adhere to my old ways at home, and do my best to fit in with the new culture’s ways everywhere else. Why should they change for me? I’m the outsider! What’s up with people believing they can move to a country and not change their ways at all?
Thanks for the meme, Robin!
Wow, another good friend has tagged me! For another meme! So, here it is!
The rules for this meme are as follows: Remove the blog in the top spot from the following list and bump everyone up one place. Then add your blog to the bottom slot.
Then you get to select five people to pass the love on to. This is the best part. Check the following blogs in the next day or two to see what they have to say about Robin and her meme.
That’s it. It’s an easy one. I am not familiar with Robin’s list so I will dash over to them before I leave for school. I’m always up for a friend’s recommendation!
Thankyouverymuch.






