You Want A Creation Theory? I'll Give You A Creation Theory!

On my Flickr page, there is a picture of a dulcimer.

Mamacita says:  Back in the day, all middle school/junior high students had to take shop and home ec. They entered high school, and life, knowing how to use a hammer and nails, how to put together a simple meal, how to sew a straight seam, how to take a few simple tools and create something new or improved with them. These are life skills, not frills.

There are all kinds of creation, and an essay or mathematical equation or scientific proof are only some of them, and not necessarily the most important ones, either.

Back in the day, all elementary students were taught about basic musical and artistic base-line skills. Students were taught to read music, and to mix colors together to make new colors. Students were taught the lyrics to hundreds of songs, and how to sing harmony, and they were also taught how to recognize different artists by their personal styles and quirky signatures.

Schools used to require the students to memorize poems, and stories, and to write original ones, too.

Students entered high school knowing the rules for games, and about sportsmanship.

Cheaters were the lowest of the low, the scum of the earth.

They still are, but public opinion has changed quite a lot, and sometimes cheaters are exalted. This must cease. (insert smirk here, for who is going to stop it? Those with the power to do so are the same ones who often exalt it. Those with the power are sometimes the cheaters.) (Principal who insisted that plagiarists retain valedictory position, for example.) (Superintendents with no internet knowledge who make judgment calls based on. . . well, nothing.)

Cheaters are the lowest of the low, the scum of the earth. They may have achieved a victory now, but the wheel of life keeps turning, and the fly on the top will be the fly on the bottom eventually. And vice versa.

Ahem.

Doing away with woodshop and home ec and music and art, to make room for more and more practice sessions of ISTEP and review sessions for those subject areas that are covered in the mandated standardized tests, has done nothing but remove a few areas wherein some students found success, and replaced them with more areas wherein these students will certainly fail.

Not everybody is a rocket scientist or a writer or a mathematician. Some people are musicians and artists and craftsmen and carpenters and chefs.

And what is a rocket scientist’s or a writer’s or a mathematician’s life without music and art and furniture and food?

I firmly believe that every student should be exposed to as much and as many diverse areas of curriculum as is humanly possible according to the limiting laws of physics. Every person should know how to cook, and sew, and use simple tools, and recognize good music from bad, and look at a piece of art and see beyond the lines and borders.

Why are our schools casting the artistic and hands-on students aside in full favor of the academic students? Yes, schools ARE academic, but schools are also the institution that is supposed to prepare our students for the future, and the future depends on people who can read, write, do the math, understand basic scientific functions. . . . and feed themselves and others, and create beautiful objects for practical and impractical use, and nourish the soul and heart as well as the brain.

Only the finite can be ‘tested;’ therefore, only the finite is stressed and even allowed in our schools, these sad, sad days.

Maybe this is why so many of our young people drop out; the schools are offering nothing for them, only for those whose talents lie within the very limited boundaries of the ISTEP test.

Maybe this is why so many of our young people vandalize; they were taught nothing about what real art is, or even respect for it.

Maybe this is why so many of our young people listen to music that isn’t really music; they’ve never heard real music. It’s a fact that when the schools dropped music as a required subject, the recording industry took up the slack, and which of these has our kids’ loyalty now, hmmm?

Maybe this is why so many of our young people associate a song with a video; they’ve never experienced the joy and wonder of learning a song within a group and having it branded on the memory like a wonderful dream, and associating it with an experience rather than a television program..

Maybe this is why so many of our young people disrespect those who make their living with their hands; the school wherein they sat for years and years never emphasized it or showed them the importance of it. On Honor Day, the prizes for those who did well in ‘those’ kinds of classes were smaller and less shiny than the big trophies for “Most Improved Math Student,” or the many “Way To Show Up, Kid” self-esteem awards.

Maybe this is why so many of our young people are anorexic and bulemic and obese and existing on lard and salt and cholesterol; they were never taught the essentials of human nutrition and how to create it themselves.

Maybe I’m being too judgmental; it wouldn’t be the first time. Maybe I’m being too simplistic; well, of course I am. But even in a judgmental and overly simplistic mindset, I still think maybe I’m on to something here.

My dulcimer was created for me by a student named Rusty, who was pretty much nothing but a big illiterate hood, by academic and behavioral standards. He failed everything but woodshop, but in the woodshop he shone like a star. Put a pencil in his hand and he could do nothing but break it in two and throw the pieces at someone. Put a piece of paper in front of him and he would probably wad it up and spit it across the room. Ask him to spell a word and he would stare helplessly. But put him in a room full of hammers and nails and glue and pliers and saws and complicated directions, and he became a genius, a maestro wielding a screwdriver, and making beauty out of a piece of raw wood.

Our shop kids used to make dulcimers; it was their big project. Beautiful musical instruments, fashioned by the hoody crud of the student body. The kids were then taught to play them, and taken around to nursing homes and business clubs to perform.

No more, of course. The woodshop has been closed and locked for many years now. There just isn’t time for it any more, what with computer tech and ISTEP prep. Besides, all field trips have been done away with. (Except for athletics, of course. You really don’t want to get me started on THAT one. . . .)

Students like Rusty, who shone at nothing but hands-on, now shine at nothing. This isn’t right.

In our schools, we have fantastic musicians and artists. Back in the day, we cherished and nurtured these incredible talents. Now, we brush them aside and pull these kids from the studios and make them study only academics, because the arts aren’t tested. And if a subject isn’t on the test, it won’t be offered; at the very least, it won’t be taken seriously.

There are six or seven periods in the school day. Three or four subjects are ‘tested.’ The State has mandated “Advisor/Advisee” time, daily; that means our kids will get some serious counseling by some seriously untrained non-counselors. Some students will have as many as three study halls every day. This is inexcusable.

Of course, to do it all up properly would require the hiring of a few more teachers. We can’t DO that; those athletic buses and the athletic director’s five full-time assistants and the superintendent’s company car and $100,000+ salary take a lot of money.

And in many schools, the ‘special’ teachers (art, music, etc) are shared by several buildings. Ask my Tumorless Sister about her schedule back when she taught at the elementary level, why don’tcha. It’s a moral disgrace. As parents, and as citizens, we should make our outrage at this misuse of talent known, with our voices and our votes.

Our children are more than a piece of paper with a few numbers on it.


Comments

You Want A Creation Theory? I'll Give You A Creation Theory! — 10 Comments

  1. Oh, don’t get me started on athletics or counseling or any of those. I do believe academics should be the core but most schools are even failing in that department these days by hiring teachers who can’t teach or who are only interested in the “stars”.
    The day my youngest graduated from high school was the happiest day of my life – my full-time job for 18 years had been volunteering in (read “keeping an eye on”) our schools. I was soooo tired by the time she grabbed that diploma.

  2. Oh, don’t get me started on athletics or counseling or any of those. I do believe academics should be the core but most schools are even failing in that department these days by hiring teachers who can’t teach or who are only interested in the “stars”.
    The day my youngest graduated from high school was the happiest day of my life – my full-time job for 18 years had been volunteering in (read “keeping an eye on”) our schools. I was soooo tired by the time she grabbed that diploma.

  3. We need balance in our schools! I think students need the challenge and the academic rigor, but allowing students to explore arts or vocational areas can only serve to enhance their lives. Or…maybe it’s the other way around. Learning to develop one’s vocational or artistic aptitude while taking on challenges in core academics can only serve to enhance life. In an educational system where diversity is so celebrated, it seems we aren’t walkin’ the walk.

  4. We need balance in our schools! I think students need the challenge and the academic rigor, but allowing students to explore arts or vocational areas can only serve to enhance their lives. Or…maybe it’s the other way around. Learning to develop one’s vocational or artistic aptitude while taking on challenges in core academics can only serve to enhance life. In an educational system where diversity is so celebrated, it seems we aren’t walkin’ the walk.

  5. I loved shop, and being one of the few girls in my class made the boys look at me curiously wondering why I wanted to make a CO2 car or Mousetrap car instead of learning to sew. However, in Home Economics, I loved cooking. I still love cooking. But being able to use a Table Saw, Hammer, and Nails was kind of musical in its on right. However, I loved Music and Art as well. It’s sad that the School Districts are doing away with these wonderfully enriching classes….it’s sad that the doors have been shut and locked for quite some time…Pity that the machines they paid top dollar for back in the day are being used to collect dust…Where’s their money now?

  6. I loved shop, and being one of the few girls in my class made the boys look at me curiously wondering why I wanted to make a CO2 car or Mousetrap car instead of learning to sew. However, in Home Economics, I loved cooking. I still love cooking. But being able to use a Table Saw, Hammer, and Nails was kind of musical in its on right. However, I loved Music and Art as well. It’s sad that the School Districts are doing away with these wonderfully enriching classes….it’s sad that the doors have been shut and locked for quite some time…Pity that the machines they paid top dollar for back in the day are being used to collect dust…Where’s their money now?

  7. My school actually has a wood shop and program AND also welding.
    They make really cool stuff to benefit the school/other programs’ a
    and get a lot of positive feedback and kudos. I know what you
    mean about most schools though–they only get recognition as
    “the best” if they have more students who take the AP test,
    which many kids have no interest in or aptitude for. Not everyone
    is college prep! However, our music teachers do often travel
    these days, especially the orchestra ones. 🙁

  8. My school actually has a wood shop and program AND also welding.
    They make really cool stuff to benefit the school/other programs’ a
    and get a lot of positive feedback and kudos. I know what you
    mean about most schools though–they only get recognition as
    “the best” if they have more students who take the AP test,
    which many kids have no interest in or aptitude for. Not everyone
    is college prep! However, our music teachers do often travel
    these days, especially the orchestra ones. 🙁

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *